Showing posts with label intrinsic motivation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intrinsic motivation. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 31, 2019

What the Hand Does, the Mind Remembers


“What the hand does, the mind remembers.” – Dr. Maria Montessori


Children remind me that they learn with their hands, something Dr. Montessori understood through quiet observation over a century ago. This continues to be true in the current time of digital technology (literally: tools used by the hands) and an adult focus on abstraction as a metric of success. I have grappled with the inclusion of technology and testing in the Montessori classroom, in both private and public charter environments, and I continue to believe that they are incongruous with the beautiful and patient process of a child learning by holding actual objects – clay, fossils, fern fronds – with their hands.

“Do not tell them how to do it. Show them how to do it and do not say a word. If you tell them, they will watch your lips move. If you show them, they will want to do it themselves.” – Dr. Maria Montessori

A few years ago, I asked a mother of one of my students to come in and demonstrate how she makes her own kombucha. There were simple ingredients and a live bacteria, which we stored in our room for weeks and watched grow, documenting its bubbling surface and the layers that it formed in a controlled environment. It is much easier to just buy a bottle of kombucha at a store, however the children looked forward to being a part of the process – using gloves to touch the SCOBY, selecting the flavors to add. Convenience is not always possible nor preferable. It often stalls understanding.

"The senses, being explorers of the world, open the way to knowledge." – Dr. Maria Montessori







In the Montessori learning environment, especially the expansive Cosmic Curriculum, there are many varieties of concrete materials – from the wooden Bohr diagram modeling the inside of an atom to the Timeline of Life with era boxes full of fossils to the Land and Water forms (used with colored water poured from a jug). Many of these initial materials have extensions which allow interested children to go deeper. For example, many children choose to make their own Land and Water booklet with brown and blue paper, or (in this case, shown above) models formed by painting dried clay models.

When I think about the ways in which public education (and, often, adult thinking in general) prioritizes large quantities of superficial, one-time-only lessons – some of which are never reviewed nor returned to – I feel thankful that Montessori education functions in the exact opposite manner. Children are encouraged to go deeper, to be reiterative, to be creative with a concept, making the trench of the neural pathways surrounding it that much further ingrained.

“Education is a natural process carried out by the child and is not acquired by listening to words but by experiences in the environment.” – Dr. Maria Montessori



Children learn about Parts and Kinds in Montessori education, from math to language to science:

Parts of the Atom and Kinds of Atoms

Parts of a Line and Kinds of Lines

Parts of Speech and Kinds of Words

Children are attracted to the largest things and the smallest things. When we study the Coming of the Earth, we find an inter-relatedness with the Inner Earth and the Plate Tectonic activity that caused and causes land forms to exist, that allowed animal and eventually human migration to occur. Children are fascinated by superlatives: the highest, the furthest, the smallest, the coldest, the hottest. Again, it would be easier to simply purchase a model of a volcano from a craft store. However, witness these children forming volcanoes with their own hands!

“The hands are the instruments of man’s intelligence.” – Dr. Maria Montessori




It is amazing to be alive, and children in Lower Elementary also come to a knowledge that death is something that belongs to all things. We study life cycles of living things, such as a tree or a jellyfish, and we also know where our Universe is in its own lifespan. (Like me, it’s middle-aged!) This knowledge of the ephemeral quality of nature is deepened when children see the Timeline of Life, specifically how old the world is, how old other organisms are (like the jellyfish, one of the longest lived creatures on the planet), and how young we humans are as a species. When we study the life cycle, we see the same phases and know that each organism is unique and special.

“The human hand allows the mind to reveal itself.” – Dr. Maria Montessori



One of the most inspiring things to see is what children create from their own imaginations. When they use geometric building blocks as a Practical Life activity, they are resting their reading mind and engaging their body – their kinesthetic and tactile intelligences. They are using the concept of gravity when they balance an arch on a cone. They are using the concept of symmetry when they build a structure out of rectangular prisms, pyramids, and cylinders. Mainly, though, they are free to experiment, make mistakes, try again, and eventually hopefully innovate while creating an architecture of their own happiness.

Friday, April 14, 2017

The Earliest Life Forms on Earth



Montessori’s Great Lessons give the universe to the child and encourage discoveries. After the expansive First Great Lesson: The Coming of the Universe (which incorporates astronomy, chemistry, and physics), Montessori 6-9 year-old children explore the Second Great Lesson: The Coming of the Earth. In addition to hearing stories from various cultures around the world about how our planet came to be, children are also told the evolving story of the Earth’s history as told by the scientific community through facts, evidence, and the Scientific Method.


The Second Great Lesson: The Coming of the Earth incorporates geology, physical geography, and biology. The life sciences shine during this curricular study of the earliest life forms on the planet. Having explored the smallest particles of matters, atoms, in the previous Great Lesson, here children learn about kinds of cells – prokaryote and eukaryote – which led to bacteria such as protists and early plant life in the form of cyanobacteria. 



In my current Montessori-hybrid charter environment, we explored cell structures – their parts and how they function, as well as how they differ. One of the most popular lessons I give involves using egg yolks and a fork to discriminate between the two main kinds of cells.


Children are motivated to read about and identify the parts of the cells using three- or four-part card Zoology materials. (Three-part cards feature an image, a label, and a combined image and label card. Four-part cards are mainly used in 6-9 and 9-12 learning environments for children with advanced decoding and reading comprehension skills.) After learning about prokaryote and eukaryote cells, children investigate which kinds of living things contain these kinds of cells. They then may choose to make models with objects representing different parts. These extensions deepen and broaden connections children will later make when they concern themselves with more advanced life forms.


As we move into the Timeline of Life that began with the Proterozoic Era of Earth History, children lay out the timeline (color-coded by era). 


They see just how long one main life form – the cnidarian (one example of which is a jellyfish) -- existed virtually alone on the planet, evolving and adapting as the world became cleaner due to adaptations of plant and animal life filtering the air and water of acid rain produced by volcanic off-gassing. 




These invertebrates paved the way for later animal forms to create skeletons and become vertebrates, and they remain some of the longest life forms in existence, due in large part to the gift they made of their bodies for the lives of others.





Sunday, November 15, 2015

Practical Life Activities Engage the 6-9 Child

In the Lower Elementary Montessori classroom, students enjoy a balance of Language, Cultural, and Math studies using concrete academic materials designed by Maria Montessori over a hundred years ago. In addition, children ages 6-9 enjoy hands-on Practical Life work which includes:
  • sorting activities (which is a pre-math skill),
  • pin-poking shapes, such as a continent or country puzzle piece (which aids in handwriting), 
  • sewing, 
  • playing a melody harp (which gives a gentle calm to the bustling classroom environment), 
  • cooking food to share with the class, 
  • making designs on a geometric board with colorful rubber bands, 
  • building architectural models of real buildings which we are currently studying, 
  • gardening (or watering indoor plants during winter months), 
  • doing yoga exercises (asanas) with a partner or by oneself,
  • and walking a peace labyrinth. 

Practical Life activities build a child’s motor development from fine to gross -- strengthening both the pincer grip involved in legible penmanship and the patience needed to remain engaged with a project for a length of time. Practical Life also provides students with opportunities to explore their senses and enjoy activities related to the life of the community. Practical Life is indeed a “practical” skill which the child notices improves the more s/he practices it. A child is intrinsically motivated to cook, to sew, or to build. 



This type of activity grounds a person emotionally and physically, allowing him/her the space and time to make something beautiful, delicious, or intricate. In this way, the spiritual life of the Montessori student blossoms, in giving to others and in caring for oneself. Practical Life is the essence of Montessori's Peace Education.



Sunday, May 6, 2012

Nourishing the Intellect in Nature


On a recent field trip to Full Circle Farm in Carnation, Washington, my class of 6-9-year-olds had a special experience in nature. Throughout the month of September, we had been studying the changing seasons, sketching farm animals, reading books about food, and had even taken our families to a local farmer's market to see the produce up-close. On our field trip -- which was free -- we wore mud boots so we could get dirty and explored the farm with a volunteer guide. We examined various seeds that are stored in the barn and smelled various geraniums with amazing perfumes (lemon balm, pepper, tomato) in the greenhouse where seeds flourish into plants. We also visited the manure-to-compost heap, saw the vintage farm equipment this local farm buys used as a form of recycling, and snacked on carrots from the field and blueberries off the vine. Although this farm is within thirty minutes of our school, this event was many students' first foray onto a farm where organic food is grown in a sustainable way.
I was reminded of Richard Louv's term "nature-deficit disorder". Children at first felt inhibited to splash in puddles, wary of dirtying their clothes, and they learned that some bacteria (among the oldest and earliest forms of life on the planet) are actually good for you, that they fight sickness created by "bad" bacteria. A parent mentioned that her child is reading voraciously this year, since television viewing was decreased. So many things that impact all of our lives end up seeming very simple. The more in-touch we are with hands-on materials, the more focus, concentration, and enjoyment we experience. Technology has much to offer us, yet we benefit from maintaining equal time with low-mechanized or even manual processes: peeling a potato, holding a door for another person, or turning a page.
In Richard Louv's two books on the subject of nature-deficit disorder, Last Child in the Woods and The Nature Principle, the author does not oppose technology yet reminds readers that the more technology we introduce and use in our lives, the more nature we need to bring about balance. Even a small amount of time outdoors positively affects children whose connection to the environment has been negatively impacted by increasingly sedentary or (conversely) over-structured lifestyles.
Fundamental aspects of Montessori education parallel recent scientific studies on the optimal ways we learn: 
  • through hands-on contact with natural materials
  • by going out into the world to freely experience (not simply research)
  • in communion with others
  • through noticing inter-connections between all life forms
  • in honoring our whole selves -- intellect, emotions, body, sense of wonder, need for company
  • and by finding peace at our own pace. 
Here are some suggestions for restoring a child's connection to nature:
  • Walking, journaling, and engaging in imaginative play outdoors -- with or without others -- may bring a child inner peace and joy or provide centering instead of over-stimulation.
  • Those who are naturally creative and imaginative may enjoy sketching or watercolor, which also strengthen fine motor skills.
  • Climbing trees, building forts, or relays may allow a child to develop unknown sources of physical strength.
  • Those who grapple with hypersensitivity or defensiveness may benefit from spending more time outside in order to release frustrations and find peace when compromise is necessary.
  • Time spent with friends and loved ones in nature settings may help a child feel more secure, allow him/her to take risks and try new things, and develop courage and confidence.
  • Many active children find that running or jumping rope helps them corral their energy and focus better indoors, as well as provides them with a break between periods of deep concentration.
  • Shy or reticent children may benefit from oral storytelling which inspires the senses and stimulates conversation.
  • Gardening may help children connect to others and the natural world, refine their auditory and visual senses, and enhance observance of their surroundings.
  • Collective excursions  -- especially hiking, camping, or adventuring -- allow children to express themselves more openly to others, build self-esteem, and hone gross motor coordination.
Quality time spent with one another, rather than distracted by convenience and electronics, brings us closer and helps us feel that we belong. In PE activities, we sometimes use a colorful parachute to encourage community-building. Other times, we walk a fabric labyrinth to experience focus, patience, and mindfulness while also practicing gross motor balance. We should always go out into nature, not only during "good weather". We learn so much from returning to the same places throughout the year, noticing seasonal changes, and appreciating the cycle of life.

Intrinsic Motivation & Montessori

Alfie Kohn, a phenomenal educator and author of books such as Unconditional Parenting: Moving from Reward and Punishments to Love and Reason, speaks about intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation in the classroom and at home. Montessori philosophy emphasizes respect for the child's self-esteem and self-determination and de-emphasizes praise, adult approval, and performance-based rewards.  It takes a long time to learn how to give feedback that is free of personal attachment yet offers detail and attention.  At times, students say things like:  

"I have to get all my works done, or I can't play video games tonight."

"My mom said if I do ______ this week, she will buy me ________."

"My dad will pay me $____ for every math fact I learn."
A consistent message at home and school is vital to a sense of harmony and logic in your child.  At school, Montessori teachers encourage students to balance their activities and challenge themselves, yet we also remember the four other aspects of the person besides the intellectual: spiritual, emotional, physical, and social.  Teachers look at each child individually and avoid comparison, while also setting realistic goals with (not for) the child so s/he can feel successful.  The idea behind intrinsic motivation is to help build self-esteem, independence, and self-motivation in the child so s/he is motivated by interests, personal goals, and internal desires -- not money, punishment, and material rewards.  

Daniel Pink, author of A Whole New Mind and Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us, theorizes that changes within society are moving toward intrinsic motivation and away from external rewards.  Rewards may encourage improved performance or increased effort, but Pink and many contemporary scientists agree that results are short-sighted and may undermine the innate desires that often foster innovation, creativity, and fulfillment: "Rewards can deliver a short-term boost -- just as a jolt of caffeine can keep you cranking for a few more hours.  But the effect wears off -- and, worse, can reduce a person's longer-term motivation to continue the project." (p. 8)  Pink calls this the carrot and stick effect and identifies seven ways in which external rewards do not work:

They can extinguish intrinsic motivation.
They can diminish performance.
They can crush creativity.
They can crowd out good behavior.
They can encourage cheating, shortcuts, and unethical behavior.
They can become addictive.
They can foster short-term thinking. (p. 59)
The only case in which a reward or punishment is at all helpful is when the desired action is simply mechanical, requiring little or no cognitive ability or creativity (p. 62)  -- the opposite of learning, in or out of school. This message relates to our mission for the long-term benefit of children. We Montessori teachers guide children with practical life skills, intellectual inspiration, hands-on work (prior to abstraction), peaceful solutions, care for the environment and one another, and that Montessori phrase that echoes in my mind every day: “follow the child.”  Sometimes, teachers notice students rushing through their work, jumping to abstraction, or lacking depth in their studies.  Often this can be traced back to a misguided (and often adult-fostered) belief that quantity trumps quality.  As a Montessorian, I disagree: faster does not mean better.

Parents sometimes ask teachers, “How do I encourage my child without resorting to bribery?”  

  • Rather than using a reward to motivate a child's behavior, emphasize the behavior you value and demonstrate how you honor that behavior in your own life.  
  • Acknowledge virtues like consistency, concentration, honesty, and helpfulness.  Encourage balance and moderation, as well as following one’s passion and respecting that everyone works differently at his/her own pace.  These are the same actions that we Montessorians strive to model in the classroom. 
Adults are often interested in efficiency, not process, and ... often shift from doing too much for a child to nagging him/her about not being suddenly, completely independent. As Daniel Pink mentions in his book, extrinsic motivators perpetuate either compliance or defiance, because rewards and punishments require an authority making the choices.  Intrinsic motivators, on the other hand, involve either engagement or disengagement (p. 110), which allows the child to remain in charge of his/her own choices.  Adults can help guide, only when necessary, the inspiration at the heart of dignity, hard work, and concentration. Adults who model those virtues make a world of difference to children.

In the long run, sending your child to a Montessori school where s/he is guided in this manner and following through with your child in the same way at home makes an amazing impact on your child's life, without external motivators like money and groundings. Montessori students learn from the environment (which includes culture, problem-solving, and materials) to value their interests as the focus of their auto-education -- above and beyond the adult marketplace values of materialism. Individual pace, inspiration, and the wide arena of study available within the Cosmic Curriculum act as a primary drive in pursuing knowledge through openness to learningUsing external motivators diminishes the value of education, altruism, and compassion by making it a chore for which a person must be "bought off" in order to perform.  Children learn now what to value for the rest of their lives.  Hopefully, with our help, they will lead with their hearts and minds, not simply follow the carrot. 

Sunday, April 15, 2012

Unconditional Parenting & Montessori

In reading Alfie Kohn's 2005 book Unconditional Parenting: Moving from Rewards and Punishments to Love and Reason, some passages have given me pause to reflect:
"We might say that discipline doesn't always help kids to become self-disciplined... There's a big difference, after all, between a child who does something because he or she believes it's the right thing to do and one who does it out of a sense of compulsion... if we place a premium on obedience at home, we may end up producing kids who go along with what they're told to do by people outside the home, too." (pp. 6-7)
Kohn discusses BF Skinner and Behaviorism, a tendency to focus solely on actions and not on the feelings nor thoughts behind them.  Montessori philosophy encourages self-discipline.  Teachers act as guides, respecting the child through use of inquiry in three-part lessons and discussion in groups.  Students engage with questions rather than parrot anticipated answers.  Through problem-solving and reading literature related to social skills, students give suggestions for finding peaceful solutions to problems. It is often helpful to ask a child a question and let him/her find an answer rather than making unsolicited demands or nagging.
"Perhaps you've met (adults) who force ... children to apologize after doing something hurtful or mean... So (they) assume that making children speak this sentence will magically produce in them the feeling of being sorry, despite all evidence to the contrary?... Compulsory apologies mostly train children to say things they don't mean -- that is, to lie." (p. 14)
A few years ago, a precocious student had a rough time respecting my assistant.  I spoke with the child after an unpleasant event between them and listened to his side of the story. I then tried to facilitate peace by asking him to apologize to my assistant, either in verbal or written form.  He said that he could apologize to her, but he wouldn't mean it.  I asked if he could consider ways in which he could be more respectful to her, instead.  He came up with many ideas, none of which involved pretending he was sorry when he wasn't.
Kohn quotes noted psychologists Richard Ryan and Edward Deci (also quoted by Daniel Pink in Drive) asserting that "children are born not only with certain basic needs, including a need to have some say over their own lives, but also with the ability to make decisions in a way that meets their needs", what Ryan and Deci term "a gyroscope of natural self regulation" which can be undermined by guilt, needless interference, physical force, criticism, and even praise: "a heavy handed (adult) does nothing to promote, and actually may undermine, children's moral development.  Those who are pressured to do as they're told are unlikely to think through ethical dilemmas for themselves" (pp. 58-59).  Lack of self-regulation also impacts, Kohn observes, personal health choices, social relations, interests, commitments, and acquisition of learning.  Alternatives are for adults to exercise restraint in interactions with children, remember to respect children as people, ask questions rather than make assumptions, separate emotional reactions from the child's will, and say "I notice" when observing behaviors rather than ascribing a positive or negative judgment.
One of the contentious suggestions that Kohn makes in this book and some of his others is that grading negatively impacts students.  He cites studies that demonstrate this and claims that "the more a child is thinking about grades, the more likely it is that his or her natural curiosity about the world will start to evaporate" (p. 80).
After hearing Kohn speak last fall, I shared some of his ideas with the students in my class at a class meeting, a democratic gathering where topics and suggestions are discussed.  I had noticed that when math fact and spelling tests were handed back for correction with a numeric grade on the paper, students compared themselves to one another, some bragging and some feeling disappointed in their abilities.  Some adults feel that competition is a natural part of life "in the real world" that children will eventually have to face, and while I agree with that unfortunate fact, I do not feel that grades as such need to be transparent to students.  I suggested a trial period where grades would be recorded by me but not shown on the paper, only the grammatical and mechanical corrections.  That was six months ago, and no one has complained about their absence.  In fact, I have noticed that students are less self-aware and more confident when given these protective options.  Our school reports S and S+ "marks" at the 6-9 level with extensive narrative descriptions that many contemporary education researchers advocate, as well.
Kohn offers some guiding principles for expressing unconditional love by avoiding rewards and punishments, which include keeping your eye on long-term goals, talking less and asking more, attributing to children the best possible motive consistent with the facts, saying yes more than saying no, and avoiding rigidity and hurrying a child according to your needs (p. 119-120).  Sometimes, we adults who have become accustomed to our own schedules expect the world to know our timetable and are flummoxed when traffic does not stop for us.  Plan ahead and know your child so that you can help him/her instead of asking for frequent adaptation to your expectations. This means avoiding over-planning and making sure, whenever possible, that your child's needs come first. For example, a child told me recently that he hadn't slept well the night before, and the reason he was late to school was that his mom let him sleep in so he would be alert.  I applaud this parent for thinking of her child's needs.  One of the most salient suggestions Kohn offers are three questions for adults to ask themselves regarding their speech and actions with children (and it also applies to our interactions with adults): why am I asking this, is it necessary, and how will the other person receive it (p. 158-160)?
Montessori education -- which provides a prepared, sequential, and orderly scope and sequence of curriculum -- gives students a range of choices for their auto-education.  We guides give lessons, yet much of the learning that happens in our classrooms occurs through the materials teaching the students as frequently as needed for absorption and as rarely as needed after abstraction.  Materials make great guides, because they do not praise nor punish, but simply offer a control of error, another of Maria Montessori's amazing insights over a century ago.  Autonomy does not mean independence but volition, and children are more willing and eager in situations where they feel they have choice.
As Kohn notes, "when teachers give their students more choice about what they're doing... the advantages include greater perceived competence, higher intrinsic motivation, more positive emotionality, enhanced creativity, a preference for optimal challenge over easy success, greater persistence in school, greater conceptual understanding, and better academic performance" (p. 169).  That is, after all, what every teacher wants for her students, what every parent wants for his child, and what every student wants for him/herself.